Skip to main content

Participatory medicine

 Reflecting on my experiences as a patient advocate and a physician, I’ve seen both the strengths and the shortcomings of participatory medicine in action. Each patient’s journey has been unique, with moments of progress and empowerment, but also instances of struggle, especially when navigating issues like privacy, confidentiality, and security.


The Good


One of the most rewarding aspects of participatory medicine is seeing patients and their families become actively involved in care. For example, in the case of the 65-year-old man with chronic vomiting, there was a clear effort to include the patient in discussions about his symptoms and potential diagnoses. This active participation helped foster trust and engagement, even though the diagnostic journey was long.


In chronic conditions like HFpEF and CKD, I’ve seen how educating patients about their disease helps them feel more in control. It’s encouraging to witness patients taking ownership of their health by asking questions and following through with treatment plans. Family involvement has also been a vital part of this process, especially for elderly patients who might struggle to advocate for themselves. In many cases, family members act as the patient’s voice, ensuring their needs are communicated and addressed.


The Bad


Despite these positives, there have been significant challenges. Communication barriers are a recurring issue. Many patients struggle to understand medical terminology, which limits their ability to make informed decisions. This can be frustrating for them and disheartening for us as healthcare providers when we see misunderstandings lead to non-compliance or missed opportunities for better outcomes.


Privacy and confidentiality remain delicate areas. In some cases, I’ve noticed that family members or caregivers unintentionally overstep boundaries, making decisions on behalf of the patient without fully consulting them. While their intentions are usually good, it raises ethical concerns about the patient’s autonomy.


Digital security is another growing concern. With more hospitals using electronic medical records, patients sometimes express unease about how their data is stored or shared. This unease is especially evident in complex cases involving multiple specialists, where coordination requires sharing sensitive information across departments.


For vulnerable populations—like elderly patients or those with cognitive impairments—these challenges are amplified. For example, in cases of dementia or altered sensorium, consent processes often become complicated, and ensuring the patient’s voice is heard can feel like an uphill battle.


Trust issues also arise when patients feel their concerns are dismissed or not taken seriously. In the blog case, the delayed diagnosis after months of chronic symptoms could understandably make a patient question the reliability of the healthcare system.



86M, HTN, DM, CVA, Orbital Cellulitis, Sepsis


https://himajav.blogspot.com/2024/11/86m-htn-dm-cva-orbital-cellulitis-sepsis.html


• Good: The patient’s advocates had a clear understanding of his complex medical condition. This made it easier to communicate treatment plans and involve them in decision-making.

• Bad: Managing multifactorial conditions like his required a collaborative team effort. At times, gaps in coordination between specialties slowed progress, underscoring the need for better teamwork in such cases.

• Privacy and Confidentiality: The sharing of sensitive medical data between multiple teams highlighted the importance of maintaining strict privacy protocols. Fortunately, there were no breaches, but patients often expressed concerns about who could access their information.




65F, Sepsis

https://himajav.blogspot.com/2024/09/65f-sepsis.html


• Good: The patient’s attenders stayed committed to the care process, demonstrating complete trust in the team even during the most challenging times.

• Bad: Handling grief is a delicate aspect of participatory medicine. In this case, the attender’s devastation at losing their loved one led to a personal crisis, reminding us of the need for better emotional support systems.

• Privacy and Confidentiality: With emotional and ethical sensitivities involved, maintaining privacy was crucial. Sharing updates required consent at every step to avoid miscommunication or overstepping boundaries.


79M, Syncope, HTN, DM, CVA

https://himajav.blogspot.com/2024/08/79m-syncope-htn-dm-cva.html

• Good: The patient’s advocate played a crucial role in ensuring timely follow-ups and that his needs were consistently met while in the hospital.

• Bad: However, when left on his own, the patient struggled to manage his medications and care, leading to preventable hospitalization. This highlights the gap in support for patients who lack continuous advocacy.

• Privacy and Confidentiality: There were concerns about who would make decisions when the patient was alone, especially since he wasn’t always in a position to provide clear consent. Ensuring his voice was respected in such instances was a challenge.


35F, SLE, HF, CKD, HTN

https://himajav.blogspot.com/2024/07/35f-sle-hf-ckd-htn.html

• Good: Despite her critical condition, the patient remained resilient and hopeful, which was inspiring for everyone involved in her care.

• Bad: Financial instability was a significant barrier, as she couldn’t afford her medications or treatment. This ultimately led to her losing the fight for her life, a heartbreaking reminder of the inequities in access to care.

• Privacy and Confidentiality: Her financial struggles often required discussing sensitive details with external organizations for support. Ensuring her dignity and privacy in these conversations was a key concern.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MEDIASTINAL SHIFT USING 2D ECHO PROBE

 Case history 40 year male autodriver by occupation resident of Narketpally came to General medicine opd with complains of Pain abdomen since 3 days, Cough since three days and Difficulty breathing since 3 days Patient is apparently alright until 3 days ago then had complains of Epigastric pain and abdominal bloating sensation , insidious onset, intermittent , No aggravating and relieving factors. Patient consumed soda water, eno, jeera soda to alleviate symptoms Complains of Non productive cough insidious onset associated with shortness of breath progressive from grade 1 to grade 4 aggreviated on supine position and lying on right side.  History of low grade fever not associated with chills and rigor, no diurnal variations relieved with Tab PCM650 mg No complains of loss of appetite, weight loss, insomnia  No complains of Orthopnea, PND, Palpitations, profuse sweating No complaints of burning micturition, increased or decreased urine output No complains of nausea, vomiti...
Post a Comment
Read more

74M CHF HTN DM PROSTATE CA

  74 male from jalalpuram came with complaints of sob and chest pain since 3 days  Patient was born and brought up in jalalpuram,lived along with parents and 3 siblings,studies till 9th standard,no health issues in childhood, discontinued education and entered carpenter work at 16 yrs of age. He got married at age of 21 years and had 3 sons and 1 daughter and lead a relatively healthy life, Patient remained asymptomatic till 14 years ago then he developed tingling sensation and weakness of limbs intermittently for which he went to local hospital and was diagnosed of having high blood pressures around 200/100 and was started on anti hypertensives,he was continuing medication and his bp was under control and remained asymptomatics until 7 yrs ago, At that time he had h/o burning micturition along with pain and dribbling of urine ,he went to local hospital for that and was diagnosed of having prostatic carcinoma and resection of tumor was done at that time and also used medicatio...
Post a Comment
Read more

48F MND HTN DM CVA

  48 year female born and bought up in thopicherla to a family of 6 members including four siblings , mother and father. achieved normal milestones. Childhood was pleasant. Father used to do pottery. When I asked how much is the income of her father and that people only buy mud pots only during summer, how would family earn money in other seasons- patient answered that summer is a great business deal for us, but there are many other occasions like temple room,weddings, funerals etc where people use mud pots .  Her teacher is a male and alcoholic who used to beat kids, in fear of that she stopped going to school. At age 9 patient had pain abdomen which was diagnosed as appendicitis and underwent appendectomy  She lost her father 15 years ago due to old age. Mother is now older than 100 years bedridden stays at her elder sister home Later she lost her elder brother due to cancer at Osmania General hospital At age 18 patient attained menarche, in the same year she was marrie...
Post a Comment
Read more